Divergent Tabletop Wiki

Pda By Pdaers

14 min readEdit

Pathological Demand Avoidance (pda)

Understanding Pda Fundamentals

What Is Pathological Demand Avoidance

PDA is a Neurological condition characterized by a pathological (hardwired, involuntary) drive to avoid everyday demands. A “demand” encompasses not just commands and requests, but expectations, pressures, and even self-imposed requirements. Critically, anything not generated by the person with PDA in that moment constitutes a demand, regardless of whether it’s something they want to do or enjoy.

The paradox of Demand avoidance: PDAers often avoid activities they genuinely want to do and enjoy. This includes hobbies, socializing with friends, and even basic self-care tasks. The avoidance isn’t about dislike or laziness—it’s a Neurological response triggered by the perception of external control or expectation.

Physical experience: Demand avoidance triggers immediate fight-or-flight response activation in the amygdala. People describe this as:

  • Tightening in the head and jaw
  • Anxiety and panic responses
  • Feeling like pushing same-pole magnets together
  • Being trapped with no options
  • Claustrophobic sensations
  • “Electric storm” in the frontal lobes
  • Trying to push through treacle (thick resistance)

Core Pda Characteristics

Key features of PDA:

Important distinction: PDA is not the same as oppositional defiant disorder or simple defiance. The avoidance is Neurological and involuntary—not a choice or behavioral pattern that can be overcome through willpower or consequences.

Anxiety in Pda

Pervasive Baseline Anxiety

Most adult PDAers experience constant low-to-moderate anxiety that becomes their baseline normal. This creates a phenomenon where anxiety goes unnoticed until reaching crisis levels. As one contributor described: “A fish doesn’t know what water is”—constant anxiety becomes invisible when it’s someone’s entire lived experience.

Delayed recognition: Many PDAers don’t realize they’re anxious until middle age or later. One person’s GP pointed out she was having a panic attack she hadn’t noticed, leading to the realization that she’d been experiencing them constantly for decades without awareness.

Anxiety Manifestations

Physical symptoms:

  • Racing heart and palpitations
  • Knots in stomach
  • Shaking and trembling
  • Difficulty breathing or hyperventilation
  • Tension in jaw and head
  • Eye twitching
  • Migraines
  • Sleep disruption (minds won’t turn off)
  • Excessive sweating and dry mouth

Anxiety-to-anger pathway: Unlike typical anxiety presentations that manifest as worry or fearfulness, PDA anxiety frequently appears as:

  • Anger and irritability
  • Control-seeking behaviors
  • Rage or aggressive responses
  • “Lava in a volcano” sensation

This mislabeling of anxiety as anger creates Diagnostic confusion and inappropriate interventions.

Anxiety and Demand Avoidance Cycle

When PDAers avoid tasks, they often can’t stop thinking about them. The unfinished demand creates a “cacophony of alarm bells” that doesn’t cease until they face the task. Some deliberately provoke themselves into anger to create motivation to complete avoided tasks.

Control, Uncertainty, and Authority

Need for Control and Predictability

PDAers have a profound need to know what’s happening and what to expect. This stems from requiring predictability to feel safe, not from a desire for power over others.

Control vs. Power: Control enables understanding and choice; power typically implies domination. PDAers consistently reject the idea that their need for control reflects a desire for power over people. As one contributor stated: “I need complete control over my life but not over others (anymore). I’ve realised that it’s not right or fair to control others.”

Intolerance of Uncertainty

Recent research shows intolerance of uncertainty scores higher than anxiety in PDA children, suggesting it may be more fundamental than previously understood.

What uncertainty intolerance feels like:

  • Sudden, unexpected changes send anxiety “through the roof in seconds”
  • Uncertainty about expectations creates particular distress
  • Being kept “in limbo” is unbearable
  • Even safe situations cause anxiety when outcomes are unknown

The uncertainty paradox: When PDAers have control over outcomes and responses, uncertainty can feel like freedom and reduce anxiety. When uncertainty involves others’ actions or schedules, it triggers severe anxiety responses.

Authority and Hierarchy

PDAers typically show little deference to authority based solely on position. They respect reasoning and collaboration but resent arbitrary rules.

Effective authority:

  • Provides clear reasoning behind requests
  • Values PDAer opinions and input
  • Uses respectful communication
  • Explains logical and ethical justification for rules

Ineffective approaches:

  • “Do it because I said so” mentality
  • Arbitrary rules without explanation
  • Hierarchical expectations without justification
  • Micromanagement and excessive oversight

Wording matters significantly: “KEEP OFF THE GRASS” triggers resistance; “Please do not walk on the grass because it erodes easily” is more likely to gain compliance.

Masking and Hidden Struggles

The Nature of Pda Masking

Most adult PDAers mask extensively, often without full awareness. Masking is an involuntary survival strategy and social requirement that comes at enormous psychological cost.

Involuntary masking: Many contributors report masking is unconscious and involuntary—they didn’t choose to do it but discovered they were already doing it, sometimes for their entire lives. One contributor describes it as “becoming someone else” when stepping outside their home, like a magical transformation they couldn’t control.

Forms of masking:

  • Going completely unobvious during meltdowns
  • Mimicking behaviors and social codes
  • Using formal language or “lawyer voice”
  • Appearing highly social while being internally isolated
  • Presenting as charismatic through eloquence
  • Adopting specific personas from observed people
  • Using physical presentation as protective barrier

The Cost of Masking

Exhaustion and recovery: Extended masking requires significant recovery time. One person noted: “It takes more energy for me to stop myself masking than it does to mask in the first place.”

Identity impacts:

  • Loss of sense of self
  • Inability to express true needs
  • Relationships based on the mask rather than authentic person
  • Delayed meltdowns after social interaction
  • Progressive inability to maintain the mask as fatigue accumulates

Long-term consequences: Over decades, extended masking leads to:

  • More severe collapse and mental health deterioration
  • Suicidal ideation and psychiatric hospitalization
  • Failed relationships and career difficulties
  • Complete Burnout and inability to function

Overload and Meltdowns

Understanding Overload

Overload is bombardment that causes the brain to “revolt” saying “Enough!” It creates confusion, disorientation, and panic. Overload can manifest as:

Types of overload:

Meltdown Manifestations

Meltdowns are involuntary Neurological responses fundamentally different from tantrums. They involve overwhelming emotional intensity that prevents reasoning or de-escalation.

Fight Response:

  • Screaming, shouting, swearing
  • Destructive behavior (throwing/breaking objects)
  • Self-harm (hair pulling, scratching, headbanging)
  • Physical aggression toward others or property

Flight Response:

  • Panic-driven escape from situations
  • Running or speed-walking away
  • Leaving situations abruptly even in public

Freeze Response:

  • Shutdown and becoming unresponsive
  • Rigid positioning against walls
  • Dissociation and curling into fetal position
  • Near-catatonic states

Internalized responses:

  • Seething atmosphere creation
  • Verbal assaults without physical violence
  • Self-directed harm (scab picking, cutting, head-slamming)

Recovery from Overload

Recovery strategies:

  • Physical grounding: Sitting/lying on actual ground, “earthing” (barefoot contact with earth)
  • Environmental disengagement: Seeking fresh air, open space, leaving crowded environments
  • Sensory regulation: Quiet time, silence, reducing stimulation
  • Alone time: Essential for recovery; social interaction is exhausting
  • Activity-based recovery: Reading, playing games, preferred media, time with pets

Important distinction: Recovery needs differ between social vs. Emotional overload. Social overload requires silence and alone time; emotional overload may require talking to release emotional charge.

Daily Life With Pda

What Things Are Avoided

Demand avoidance affects a bewildering range of activities, and the list differs per person and fluctuates over time.

Commonly avoided activities:

  • Bills, phone calls, paperwork
  • Household tasks (washing, ironing, cleaning)
  • School correspondence and administrative tasks
  • Answering messages and emails
  • Loud environments and social situations
  • Requesting things from others
  • Cooking and feeding family
  • Taking medications and attending appointments
  • Basic self-care (eating, drinking, toileting when needed)

Paradoxical avoidance: People often avoid things they actively enjoy:

  • Cross-stitch, piano playing, reading
  • Hobbies and recreational activities
  • Socializing with friends
  • Holidays and time with family

The Immediacy Strategy

Some PDAers develop a coping strategy of doing things immediately when they think of them, or they risk the task becoming a demand. Delayed action turns tasks into avoided demands that accumulate and create anxiety.

Lifestyle Restructuring

Effective approaches:

  • Minimize daily demands and unnecessary routines
  • Spread events out with prep and downtime
  • Maintain predictability and avoid surprises
  • Allow processing time without additional incoming information
  • Prefer email over phone communication
  • Choose clothes that don’t need ironing
  • Use batch cooking for unmotivated days
  • Reduce domestic load to essential tasks only

Workplace and Education

Employment Challenges

Employment is extremely difficult for most PDAers, yet specific Accommodations can improve outcomes.

Core workplace issues:

  • Work demands trigger avoidance
  • Wages paradoxically transform jobs into demands
  • Routine builds intolerable pressure over time
  • Recovery time is essential but rarely available

What works:

  • Flextime and time off in lieu
  • Autonomy to make decisions about what to do when
  • Ability to rearrange workspace for Sensory needs
  • Preference for teamwork over hierarchy
  • Zero-hours contracts (can refuse work)
  • Multiple different jobs for variety
  • Freelance/self-employed work
  • Roles with autonomy and minimal disturbance

Manager relationships: Micro-management triggers intense avoidance; genuine kindness, respect, and collaborative approaches work better than hierarchical structures.

School Accommodations

Traditional schools trigger Demand avoidance, Sensory overwhelm, and severe anxiety for many PDAers.

What helps PDA children flourish:

  • Control over timetable
  • Choice of preferred people to work with
  • Flexible pickup or start times
  • Incorporation of student interests
  • Quiet spaces for recovery
  • Small class sizes
  • Reduced hierarchical pressure
  • Clear, non-demanding communication

Alternative approaches: Homeschooling with autonomy, interest-based learning, and flexible pacing allows some PDAers to thrive academically. Forcing school attendance causes trauma and mental health crises that can persist into adulthood.

Coping Strategies and Techniques

Internal Motivation Tricks

Role-playing: Pretending to be filmed for TV while cleaning, or adopting a character makes tasks less demanding by bypassing avoidance through imaginary identity.

Doing the opposite: Telling oneself “I don’t need to shower” paradoxically makes showering easier because the brain then thinks “No, we are having one,” restoring autonomy.

“You don’t have to” approach: Giving oneself an out (“You don’t have to if you don’t want to”) makes tasks easier because autonomy is restored.

My choice frame: Reframing others’ requests as personal choice (“I’m only doing this because I want to, not because you asked”) reduces resentment and resistance.

Avoidance Tactics

One demand per day: Starting each day with just one “big demand” (not including basic self-care). Taking breaks between tasks.

Making lists: Creating a list of to-do items then avoiding them all while completing a different set of deliberately-ignored tasks.

Deciding not to: Sometimes deciding not to go to an event immediately removes the anxiety, and minutes before leaving time you may change your mind and go anyway.

Professional and Therapeutic Approaches

Alexander Technique: Provides physical control and comfort that can overcome negative PDA symptoms (20+ years of practice reported by one contributor).

Compassion Focused Therapy: Brain scans show it rewires threat-response patterns in the brain; reduces anxiety significantly.

Mindfulness: Brief daily practice (kept brief to not feel like a demand); rewires amygdala responses.

Person-centered counseling: Provides social skills coaching, feedback on empathy and Body language; builds self-awareness and trust.

Communication and Relationships

Demand-Reduction Communication

Because PDA individuals find demands intolerable, communication style is critically important.

Effective strategies:

  • Ask nicely rather than command
  • Use indirect language (“I wonder if you could…”)
  • Give choices between specific options
  • Use countdowns for transitions
  • Make demands into games or races
  • Use pretend play or toy intermediaries
  • Reduce demands when anxiety is high
  • Allow Stimming as self-soothing

Critical distinction: Avoid framing demands as choices and then getting angry if the person says no—this is manipulative and damages trust.

Relationship Dynamics

What PDAers need in relationships:

  • Smiles, approval, and positive feedback
  • No criticism or micro-management
  • Lots of love and emotional Support
  • Understanding and patience
  • Respect for autonomy and need for control

What triggers relationship difficulties:

  • Bad feeling and bitching
  • Micro-managing behaviors
  • Criticism (especially public)
  • Lack of understanding about PDA needs

One contributor summarized: “I need smiles, approval, no criticism and lots of love. Then I excel and work my hardest. Bad feeling, bitching and micro-managing. Then I leave.”

Parenting Pda Children

Radical Acceptance and Flexibility

Traditional parenting approaches (behavior charts, consequences, discipline, molding toward expectations) damage PDA children by reinforcing shame and triggering escalated avoidance.

Effective parenting involves:

  • Accepting the child won’t follow typical paths
  • Offering autonomy within boundaries
  • Creating psychological safety
  • Using distraction rather than confrontation
  • Avoiding emotional blackmail and coldness

The Impact of Parental Response

Positive outcomes: Children raised by accepting, emotionally warm parents who provide autonomy and alternatives report being confident and happy despite ongoing difficulties with Demand avoidance.

Negative outcomes: Harsh discipline (beating, slapping, screaming) causes lasting psychological damage and does not produce compliance. One person noted: “Beating, slapping and screaming to make a child conform doesn’t work, just makes them grow up to be glad when you die.”

The expressed need: “Just let me be” - PDA children cannot be molded to parental or societal expectations but can only flourish with authentic acceptance.

Mental Health and Crisis Prevention

Risk Factors

PDA individuals are at significant risk for mental health crises including:

Risk increases when:

  • Subject to prolonged harsh discipline or coercive parenting
  • Forced into unsustainable employment or school structures
  • Lacking recovery time and psychological safety
  • Experiencing extended masking without Diagnosis or Support
  • In relationships with people who don’t understand PDA neurology

Protective Factors

Early identification and appropriate Accommodations are critical protective factors. Understanding PDA neurology and providing appropriate Support can prevent many mental health crises.

Psychological safety: Creating environments where PDAers feel safe to be themselves without masking or constant demand pressure is essential for long-term wellbeing.

Diagnosis and Professional Understanding

Diagnostic Challenges

Masking creates serious Diagnostic challenges:

  • Some people have been refused Autism/PDA diagnoses because they “seem too normal”
  • Professionals see the mask, not the person
  • When people stop masking post-Diagnosis, they’re sometimes accused of “faking it”

Misdiagnosis patterns:

  • Anxiety and anger manifestations misdiagnosed as primary mood disorders
  • Giftedness masking learning differences and Demand avoidance
  • Behavioral issues attributed to character rather than Neurological differences

Professional Skepticism

PDA is not universally recognized among mental health professionals. Some dismiss it as rebranded oppositional defiant disorder (ODD) or Autism. Accessing appropriate Support may require seeking practitioners with specific PDA knowledge.

Key Insights and Counterintuitive Understanding

Demand Avoidance Is Primary

The conventional understanding of PDA as anxiety-driven is increasingly challenged. Research and lived experience suggest that Demand avoidance itself may be the primary Neurological driver, with anxiety and uncertainty intolerance as consequences or secondary manifestations.

Wages Paradoxically Trigger Avoidance

Multiple contributors report that being paid can transform an enjoyable activity into a demand, triggering avoidance where none existed when the work was unpaid. This contradicts Neurotypical assumptions about compensation and motivation.

Anxiety Manifests As Anger

The anxiety underlying PDA frequently presents as anger, irritability, or control-seeking rather than typical worry or fearfulness. This means PDAers and those around them may not recognize the underlying anxiety because it appears as negative emotion rather than anxious rumination.

Extended Masking Leads to Worse Collapse

The longer a PDAer maintains a mask without safe recovery time, the worse the eventual meltdown and mental health crisis. Recovery time doesn’t scale proportionally; small daily masking requires recovery time, and extended masking creates cascading deficits.

Strengths and Positive Aspects of Pda

While often discussed in deficit-focused terms, PDA includes several positive qualities:

Creative strengths:

  • Wordplay enjoyment and language creativity
  • Interest in people and social engagement (in self-directed contexts)
  • Ability to see patterns others miss
  • Unique perspectives and insights

Adaptive qualities:

  • Impulsivity as functional adaptation
  • Strong sense of justice and fairness
  • Authenticity when able to be unmasked
  • Deep empathy and understanding of others’ struggles

Resources and Support

Online Communities

Facebook Support communities provide text-based, non-hierarchical peer Support where PDAers report feeling safe and understood. These communities offer validation and practical strategies from lived experience.

Therapeutic Approaches

Compassion Focused Therapy: Has documented brain-scan evidence for rewiring threat-response patterns

Alexander Technique: Provides physical control and comfort that can overcome negative PDA symptoms

Mindfulness: Brief daily practice helps rewire amygdala responses

Person-centered counseling: Aligns with PDA needs for autonomy and understanding

Alternative Education

Options for PDAers who struggle in traditional school environments:

  • Homeschooling with autonomy-based approaches
  • Forest schools and farm schools
  • PDA-aware schools with appropriate Accommodations
  • Interest-based learning environments

External Resources